Blogging and Operational Security - A discussion

Blogging....for some it's a chance to express your opinions to the world.  It's a place to publish fiction, pilot academics, or just a good "so there I was story".  The dark side of blogging though is the very real fact that people are reading your material looking for actionable intelligence that may allow them to take action against you, your corporation, your alliance or your interests in New Eden.

The out-of-game aspects of EVE

Like many MMO's, EVE is not contained within the game itself.  There are kill boards, forums, fitting tools, skill plan modeling/monitoring programs, industrial spreadsheets, jump planners etc...  Since the game itself doesn't stop at the limits of the client, it's natural for players to pursue information and gather intel out of game for in-game use.  I know for a fact that there are people out there that are EXPERTS at sifting through publicly available information, fusing information from various sites and creating a 'picture' of who is associated with whom in game, what they do in game and what their role in their organization might be.

Considerations for the EVE online blogger

When an author is developing a piece, you must remember your audience.  Your audience is PUBLIC, which means if you're writing something you wouldn't be comfortable telling to the nearest red then you probably ought to re-think whether you want to blog about it.  If you are writing a review of your latest roam, consider whether you want to refer to your FC by name.  Do you want to advertise the name of your scouts?  What about ship types?  Do you advertise that you fly in a Drake with more gank than tank because you know you'll be the last to be primaried because you're flying a drake?  Each piece of information is valuable to someone and even though by itself the information may be harmless, it's a piece of a puzzle and after awhile you may only need a few small pieces to unlock a much more powerful piece of information.

The realities are though that this is a game and a majority of people blog because they enjoy it.  Operational security is important but it has to be kept in context.  We're not talking about real lives at stake or something that would demand actual information security protocols be followed, but like everything else in life, too much of a good thing can have unfortunate consequences.  Balance is the key here, there is no reason why you shouldn't write up a story about your latest roam but it might be prudent to be more general in your details.  It's one thing to say " I was flying through Providence and Catch last night with my friends on our nightly roam" and quite another to say " We camped the Keberz gate in HED-GP last night for 3 hours with a drag bubble set up from the station and a drag bubble set up from the GE jump bridge POS."

Closing thoughts

It would be dull and take the fun out of being able to share our game experience with others if we were expected to keep it sterile.  So much of what makes EVE  our game is the user developed content that grows organically well outside the scope of CCP.  As people take up blogging and become more involved in the social media aspect of the game (EVE gate anyone?) it's going to be more and more important that these risks are taken into consideration.  Ultimately, how much you the author choose to share about your game is your business.  Your corporation, alliance or gang may try to set policy or draw limits but at the end of the day, it's up to you the individual to decide how much operational security you can provide while still being able to tell your story.  My litmus test is to consider whether or not I'd be okay with convoing a war target FC and sharing what I was about to blog. Your litmus test may vary.

Thank you for writing your blog, and thank you for reading mine.  User content is what makes New Eden a community and for many a home away from home.

Evacuation.....Complete.

Rex wakes up in his 2-TEGJ jumpclone.....



Things have been hectic the last couple of weeks.  My time online has been almost exclusively dedicated to evacuating my ships, quafe and corpse collection back to empire.  With it becoming readily apparent that we were going to be bum rushed out the door by the "new holders" of Providence 2.0.1 individual members of Paxton and ultimately corporation CEO's and alliance leadership finally initiated the "GTFO" protocol and everyone began to haul their stuff out of outposts and back to empire.

For me it was an exercise in jump freighter employment.  The first time I jumped my Nomad into 2-TEGJ in mid-siege it was a "white-knuckle" moment.  I had timed the jump between red gangs and a lull in red campers.  I had set my cyno right on top of the 2-TEGJ station and jumped in.  I did have an oh-sh*t moment right after I completed the jump as I was waiting for my timer to clear so I could dock, 3 reds jumped into system.  That was the longest 20 seconds of my New Eden career.

Anyhow, things are starting to slow down, I find myself missioning to rebuild the wallet and poking around in providence. I did splurge on a new toy, I bought myself a Loki which I've enjoyed playing with and tweaking fits for.

Otherwise, Providence is now officially PXF free and while I'm sure that many of the reds are patting themselves on the back, it is probably worth noting that it took a 10:1 ratio to finally push PXF out of it's pocket.  That's a pretty respectable ratio and even though PXF lost, it's something to be proud of.

So what does the future hold for PXF?  I honestly have no clue, I'm just a line FC and the big decisions will be made by those in a position to know more and make better informed decisions.  In the end, I go where M3 goes so, the specifics aren't all that important to me.

I've made MY choice for 5th Council of Stellar Management (CSM)...who's yours?

There aren't a lot of MMO's out there that allow a group of players elected by fellow players to have a role in game development, a "voice of the people" if you will. While people have various opinions of this group, the fact remains that this is an opportunity not afforded to the population of any other MMO. Thus it is important that we carefully consider who has the ability to represent the player base and can be effective in pressing for the issues important to the pod pilots of New Eden.

I made my choice (as the title of this post would indicate) for who my 4 accounts will be voting for. I didn't make my choice based on who had the coolest website or who adapted hip-hop lyrics the most creatively. I had 3 criteria that I used to make my selection for CSM.

1) Trustworthy: To me, New Eden can be a difficult place to trust people. There are scammers and thieves and con-men so thick in places that it's hard to swing a dead cat and NOT hit one.  The CSM transcends the game, I need someone that I can trust; someone that has demonstrated the strength of their ethics and integrity.

2) Charismatic: At the end of the day, the CSM mandate is to work with game developers and as the saying goes "You catch more flies with honey". My candidate needed to have a personality and be able to engage not only the developers but also other players. A player with a chip on their shoulder or on an ego trip would piss both the developers AND the player-base off and that gets all of us no-where.

3) Engaged: Representing a diverse and divergent player base is not an easy task. It's relatively easy to represent the views of your corporation, or alliance but to really do the job like the CSM demands, each representative needs to be able to reach out to ANY player and work on ANY topic. Just because you don't mission or mine doesn't mean that as a delegate that you don't have a responsibility to weigh a potential change to one of those game aspects.  Each CSM must consider all proposals carefully and vote for the best interests of the game, regardless of personal feelings.

So.....after reading (and re-reading) the platforms, interviews and even looking at the minutes of past CSM, I made my decision.

I am casting my vote for Mynxee. You can read her platform here

Mynxee has exceeded my standards of trustworthiness both in and out of game.   She is very approachable and I might even go so far as say kind...and I don't think ANYONE can contest the point that she is engaged throughout the game.  She is a well-known blogger, EVE-podcast personality AND did you know she did the voice of Aura for Capsuleer?  Mynxee brings a wealth of personal and professional know-how to the table and makes her a natural choice for this CSM.
I urge you to cast a vote for Mynxee, but regardless of who you vote for, get out and vote today.  Your vote matters and the people you send as your representative will have an impact on New Eden for years to come!

MYNXEE FOR CSM-5

Blog Flog - 2nd Anomaly from the Left by Orakkus

Thought I'd take a moment and put a plug in for the blog of a fellow corp-mate. Orakkus has been putting up some great content over at his blog 2nd Anomaly from the Left.  His recent posts have focused on fittings in which he not only breaks into bouts of theorycrafting but also takes them out for a roadtest.

I encourage everyone to go take a look at his stuff. His most recent article "Ship Fitting Principles" uses a terri-bad fit mega (pulled from a killmail) as an example of what not to do and then discusses the fitting theory behind it.  A great read for anyone who would like to get better at their fitting skills.


What’s coming to Providence 2.0.1?

*Note:  This article is being cross-posted to this site until the CK blog pack link and the feed from the Iphone App "Capsuleer" is updated.

For those who read this blog on their RSS reader, please point your reader to the new site http://scoutsdomain.com

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This week, Paxton Federation was able to successfully repel a push from U'K and friends as they came back to engage the MH9C-S station as it's sovereignty structures came out of reinforced. As the timers ticked down to zero Paxton was able to field  a substantial sub-capital fleet of around 150 or better as well as a fleet of Carriers. As a result of some good decisions made by Paxton and some poor decisions made by the red fleet, Paxton held the field and ended the sovereignty challenge to MH9C-S.

You can read more about the engagement and the perceptions of different pilots by reading the Kutgutsumen forum Paxton Slaps Back.  What I've observed within PXF  is a lot of congratulatory back slapping and "huzzahs!" all around and rightly so.  For the first time Paxton was able to hold up against a sovereignty attack, which is more than can be said for those who lived through the downfall of Provi 1.0.  That said, there is a risk in self-congratulation and if people are not realistic in their recollection of the events the risk of over-estimating one's own capabilities can be the foundation for  ultimate downfall.

To those who have stood up and beat their chest.  It's time to get real...While Paxton did a great job of defending MH9C-S it wasn't a 'lock'.  There was the real potential that PXF would lose the system and it was a combination of good decisions made in terms of resource deployment by PXF  and bad decisions in terms of fragmented comms and inefficient fleet organization by the invaders that contributed to the PXF victory.  From an "academic" standpoint, I don't think anyone can say with certainty that, had the invaders avoided their mistakes that the outcome would have been the same.

This also wasn't the last time that PXF is going to face this threat.  U'K and the rest of the new SOV holders in Providence have made temporary alliances with the expressed purpose of seizing PXF sovereignty.  Regardless of the semantics around the deployment of a CVA TCU in AY-24I, PXF gave U'K the cover it needed to press it's invasion agenda with the current Providence administrator -A-.

There will be pilots and leaders who will disagree with my assessment, but the fact remains.  -A- set terms around it's unilaterial cessation of SOV taking hostilities with PXF. While PXF didn't make any formal agreement to adhere to those terms, the alliance leadership knew what the outcome would be if PXF undertook SOV operations.  There has been much splitting of hairs and rationalization about the actions taken by PXF and CVA that day in AY-24I.  None of that matters because at the end of the day Providence is all about realpolitik.

PXF is essentially alone in Providence.  Yes, former holders have come and fought in the recent engagements in AY-24I.  That said, there is no bat-phone to run to and expect a fleet of titans, supercarriers and dreads to show up to buttress the forces in PXF space.  Friends will come to fight, but not in numbers that will swell the ranks enough to truly determine the engagement.  CVA wasn't willing to deploy super-capitals during the seizure of all of Providence and I doubt they will do so for PXF.

-A- isn't satisfied with the results of the "grand experiment" which was to use Providence as an incubator for young PVP alliances.  While -A- was hoping to provide a foothold to these alliances, they also wanted to populate Providence and make it the happy-hunting-ground that they wanted to have on their border.  Stable, safe and a source of some easy kills. Recent comments made in forums such as Kugutsumen indicate that Providence isn't a critical interest to -A-, although any move by CVA to retake Providence would certainly draw -A- into the fight.

U'K has been against Paxton remaining in space from the beginning.  To U'K, the mere presence of Paxton represents an intolerable geo-political situation and the removal of PXF has thus been at the top of their agenda.  Some have even made claims (though unverified) that the drop of SOV in AY-24I was merely an attempt to bait Paxton into violating the conditions of the unilateral -A- armistice.  Regardless, U'K has -A-'s ambivalence (if not it's blessing) with respect to the current operation to remove PXF.

PXF is not going to quit.  PXF will fight and fight hard.  While U'K may continue to push and leverage larger alliances, PXF will continue to hold it's ground.  The seizure of PXF space will be costly for U'K and fellow reds in both time and treasure.  U'K will have to decide internally to itself and it's regional allies whether this push is worth it to them or rather that a policy of containment will yield the desired results. Containment is cheap, removal is hard.

Ultimately the future of Providence has yet to be determined but here are some things to think about:

- PXF did a great job of repelling the attack in MH9C-S but this win doesn't guarantee the same success in the future and anyone who thinks so needs to recalibrate their reality.

- The removal of an alliance that refuses to buckle (like a belt) is an expensive and intensive under taking.  U'K might have the strong desire to take the space, but is it the strategically best option when containment would be just as effective?

- With the "big" war raging, is Providence worth investing in by the big alliances?  Does Providence threaten the critical interests of Atlas or -A- or the NC?  Is it realistic to expect any of the large alliances to come to either sides aid?

Regardless of the forum banter (or this post even) things will continue to develop.  Whether the campaign by U'K and it's neighbors to force PXF out of it's space continues remains to be seen.  The coming days will certainly bring many good fights and more than a little bit of learning with it.  I urge all pilots to use these fights as opportunities to master their skills and learn from their mistakes.  Better pilots means better fights, which means a better game for everyone.

Here's to more good fights.

New Website - www.scoutsdomain.com

Well the time has come for me to leave the Blogger software behind.  After a lot of looking and considering, I've decided to host my own WordPress site over at Lonetrek Hosting

The new site is located at www.scoutsdomain.com

I'll continue to cross-post to both blogger and my new WordPress site until all the links have been updated.

Thanks for your continued readership, lots more blogging to come.

-Rex





Blog comments are on the fritz...please stand by

So I received several tweets the last couple of days about the inability for readers to post responses to my postings.  I can honestly say that I have NO idea why it isn't working and I've poked around in the blog template to see if I could find the problem.

That said, my 5 year old has a better shot at find the problem then I do.  So bear with me, I am going to consult people much smarter than me and see if they can help me fix the problem.

Until then I'll keep posting but you may not be able to rant immediately :)